You're #1

 Here's a small relic from Lyle's: a glow-in-the-dark keychain that says:

You're #1 With

LYLE'S HOBBY & CRAFT CENTER

38 N. Cass, Westmont, IL

(312) 852-8085

This is indeed a Wolverine pin that was purchased at Lyle's, probably sometime in the 1983-1984 time period. Artwork by the estimable Paul Smith.